Canada is facing a housing crisis. Could it take a page from Europe?

Slavica Salihbegovic's household was growing. So she did what anyone surviving successful Vienna would do: She asked the metropolis for a bigger apartment.

"At that time, I was large with my archetypal kid," she said. "I lived successful a two-room flat … it was an OK building, but it was tiny for us."

Salihbegovic went to an online portal, entered her income and requirements, and was ranked alongside thousands of different residents. Soon, she was assigned a caller apartment: a three-bedroom portion successful a brand-new building, adjacent to Vienna's Central Station. 

It's hers for beingness — she tin adjacent walk it down to her children, if she wants.

"I emotion it. It's successful the mediate of Vienna," she said. "A batch of young families moved successful astatine the aforesaid time…. There's a large field here, with a kindergarten and superior school. There's dancing classes, and a boulder bar, and a immense park."

Salihbegovic wasn't hopeless to find housing. She and her spouse earned middle-class incomes. But successful caller years, Vienna has go renowned among lodging experts for its exemplary of societal housing, which provides heavy subsidized rental units to much than fractional of the city's 2 million residents.

And the rent from those units helps powerfulness €400 cardinal ($626 million) successful caller operation annually, amounting to much than 12,000 units built oregon refurbished each year, according to the city.

While Europe struggles with akin trends to Canada of rising rents and skyrocketing location prices, experts accidental societal lodging models similar Austria's are among the champion defence against a increasing affordability situation — and are begging governments to proceed investing aggressively successful specified programs.

Could thing akin ever travel to Canada? It whitethorn look far-fetched, but lodging experts crossed Europe accidental it's made imaginable acknowledgment to a fewer comparatively elemental interventions.

Housing without profit

Living astir the country from Salihbegovic is Amila Sirbegovic, an designer and lodging task person for the City of Vienna. She utilized to ain an apartment, but opted to merchantability and determination backmost into societal housing, wherever she says her portion is much modern and spacious.

Sirbegovic's communicative is different illustration of what makes European societal lodging different: A generous eligibility criteria. 

Roughly three-quarters of Austrians autumn nether the income threshold, meaning galore middle-class families tin get geared-to-income housing, excessively — with rents capped astatine a tenable 25 per cent of income.

"It's the astir mean happening successful Vienna," said Salihbegovic.

The divers premix of tenants means determination is small stigma attached to subsidized housing; it besides keeps neighbourhoods divers and ensures municipality lodging is disposable for captious workers similar nurses, sanitation workers and autobus drivers.

"You person radical from antithetic groups and antithetic backgrounds surviving successful the aforesaid neighbourhood," said Gerald Kössl, a argumentation adept with Austria's Federation of Limited-Profit Housing Associations. 

"It's not seen arsenic … a impermanent lodging solution."

Kössl's enactment represents the groups providing each this low-cost lodging — non-profit oregon "limited profit" companies that are required by Austrian instrumentality to reinvest each but 3.5 per cent of their profits.

The effect is simply a "virtuous cycle" of assemblage investment, said Samara Jones, an adept with Housing First Europe.

Money that would different spell to shareholders is poured backmost into creating high-quality and affordable homes and neighbourhoods — which, successful turn, has a "price-dampening effect" connected the wider market, said Kössl.

Austria is not unsocial successful utilizing this model. Across Europe, governments negociate a information of their subsidized lodging banal done large, privately managed non-profits.

LISTEN | How overmuch are investors to blasted for the lodging crisis? 

In the Netherlands, determination are less than 300 non-profits crossed the full state — but this consolidation doesn't pb to the problems you mightiness find with the large, profit-oriented existent property concern trusts communal successful Canada.

On average, it's amended than renting connected the backstage market, said Zeno Winkels, manager of the Dutch Tenants Union, which negotiates with the authorities to acceptable rent limits crossed the country.

By comparison, astir backstage landlords are "amateurs," helium said. 

"That doesn't needfully person to beryllium negative. There are tons of radical who marque large cakes, but, successful general, erstwhile you privation a cake, you spell to a bakery."

Staking space

Of course, these non-profits can't tally connected rents unsocial — they wouldn't stay affordable for long.

The affordable lodging gathering roar successful places similar Finland, the Netherlands and Austria has ever been powered by important authorities investment. And crossed Europe, governments person devised clever ways to chopped costs.

One of the biggest has been for cities similar Vienna and Amsterdam to aggressively get onshore erstwhile it comes up for sale, done "right-to-buy" policies that springiness them archetypal dibs.

Owning the onshore allows municipalities to mandate that lodging successful cardinal areas beryllium kept affordable for a period oregon more, arsenic opposed to the 20 to 30 years often emblematic successful Canada.

Land remains costly for municipalities to buy. But successful immoderate places, similar the Netherlands, governments person fixed themselves the close to deduct the outgo of adding further services, similar roads and water, from their acquisition price, shaving tens of millions disconnected the outgo of onshore being rezoned for housing. 

Government buying is besides matched with substantial, long-term, low-interest loans to the non-profits gathering and managing the banal of affordable housing.

Those investments assistance support them accountable — and unchangeable capable to support investing successful much buildings, said Natalia Martinez, an adept with Fundacio Habitat 3, an affordable lodging supplier successful Spain.

It's an thought Canada appears to beryllium entertaining; Housing, Infrastructure and Communities Canada launched a telephone for proposals connected a "rental extortion fund" conscionable past month, aimed astatine helping non-profits and different partners get and support affordable rental units.

"Not a batch of communities person the gross root to interaction lodging proviso from their ain pocketbook," said Adrian Dingle, manager of lodging improvement for Raising the Roof Canada, an anti-homelessness non-profit.

Thinking big

Broadening the explanation of affordable lodging successful this mode — and backing it with low-interest loans — could person a large interaction successful Canada, experts say.

"I bash judge we're successful a hopeful clip erstwhile it comes to national lodging policy," said Dingle.

But erstwhile it comes to rapidly expanding affordability, those aforesaid experts are near-unanimous successful saying that much interventionist measures whitethorn beryllium indispensable — specified arsenic rent control, spot windfall taxes and steep fees for 2nd properties.

They mightiness beryllium arguable to some, but they tin beryllium effective.

WATCH | Here's however lodging co-ops work: 

In the Netherlands, the Affordable Rents Act established a mandatory formula for calculating rent, which placed caps connected definite tiers of housing, reducing mean costs by 50 per cent oregon more. 

Overnight, existent property speculation slowed and location prices dropped.

Like Austria, the Netherlands has besides been palmy successful mandating precocious percentages of immoderate caller improvement beryllium allocated to affordable lodging — "at slightest 30 per cent," said Theo Stauttener, a spouse with the developer consultancy Stad Kwadraat. That's applied not lone successful cities, but successful suburbs, wherever single-family homes marque up a ample percent of societal housing.

Experts are skeptical that Canadian governments would marque akin moves. Figures amusement Canada is good down — conscionable 3.5 per cent of Canadian lodging is societal housing, compared to an mean 8 per cent crossed Europe, and closer to 30 per cent successful places similar Austria and the Netherlands.

"I'm not definite the semipermanent readying is there, oregon the governmental will," said Sheldon Pollett, enforcement manager of Raising the Roof Canada.

But waiting for idiosyncratic other to lick the occupation hasn't worked anywhere. 

"We've been waiting for the backstage assemblage to travel and capable this spread for a agelong clip — and it hasn't," said Jones. "Certainly, 1 acquisition for Canada is this: Don't wait."

For the fortunate Viennese, similar Sirbegovic, who tin find an affordable flat with ease, the archetypal measurement is simply a alteration successful mindset. "You truly request to judge successful societal housing," she said.

Martinez puts it different way. 

"How consenting are we to see lodging a close that's up determination with wellness attraction oregon acquisition oregon our pension plans?" she asked. "Once we bash that, we spot the authorities arsenic liable for creating those conditions."