1 week ago
6
The Justice Department accused a tiny metropolis in bluish Idaho of spiritual favoritism aft it denied a zoning licence to a section evangelical religion seeking to clasp worship services.
The DOJ announced connected May 20 it had filed a suit alleging the metropolis of Troy, Idaho, violated the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIPA) aft it denied a conditional usage licence to Christ Church to clasp services successful its downtown C-1 zoning district, wherever nonreligious assembly uses specified arsenic clubs, museums, auditoriums, and creation galleries were allowed.
The RLUIPA is national authorities passed successful 2000 that’s intended to "protect individuals, houses of worship, and different spiritual institutions from favoritism successful zoning and landmarking laws," the DOJ states.
According to the lawsuit, Christ Church, a tiny but rapidly increasing evangelical religion based successful Moscow, Idaho, sought to accommodate its maturation successful September 2022 by establishing different religion field successful the neighboring municipality of Troy.
The Department of Justice announced it had filed a spiritual favoritism suit against the metropolis of Troy, Idaho, implicit its licence denial to a section church. (Getty/Michael Calene)
The conservative, evangelical religion faced absorption from immoderate successful the Moscow assemblage implicit the years due to the fact that of its beliefs and power successful the wide assemblage town, with immoderate residents boycotting businesses tied to the church, according to the Spokesman-Review.
The religion made nationalist headlines successful September 2020 aft a fewer of its members were arrested for not wearing masks astatine an extracurricular worship work protesting the city's disguise mandate during the tallness of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Senior Pastor Douglas Wilson faced disapproval for his provocative writings and allegations helium wants to marque America a "Christian theocracy," according to a caller nonfiction from Politico.
Christ Church allegedly reached retired to assorted locations successful Troy to rent connected weekends for services, without success. In November 2022, Matt Meyer, an elder astatine the religion and Troy resident, purchased a vacant, erstwhile slope successful the city’s downtown concern territory with the volition of converting portion of the spot into a abstraction to beryllium utilized by the religion for worship services and religion meetings, portion the different portion of the spot would beryllium rented retired arsenic an lawsuit abstraction for the community.
"Troy Days" successful Downtown Troy, Idaho. (BJ Swanson)
Meyer applied for a conditional usage licence and told the metropolis helium failed to find different suitable abstraction to clasp services successful Troy. In his application, helium said determination would beryllium small interaction connected the surrounding businesses and his acquisition of the vacant gathering would bring successful spot taxation gross for the city.
After holding a nationalist proceeding connected the substance wherever locals expressed beardown absorption to the licence request, the Troy City Council rejected the church's exertion successful March of that year.
According to the DOJ, the metropolis assembly denied the licence connected the ground that the religion "did not heighten the commercialized district."
Furthermore, the metropolis assembly argued the bulk of locals were against granting the religion a licence successful this portion and the determination would load residents and businesses by creating postulation and parking issues successful the city, whose colonisation is less than 1,000 people.
In their suit filed connected Christ Church's behalf, the DOJ questioned however the metropolis justified the denial connected the ground of respective of its arguments.
Matt Meyer, an elder of Christ Church, purchased a erstwhile slope successful the downtown country to person the vacant spot into an events halfway and a religion abstraction for meetings and play worship services. (Matt Meyer)
TECH COMPANY REVERSES POLICY AFTER CHRISTIAN GROUP SUES FOR RELIGIOUS DISCRIMINATION
The suit questioned wherefore the metropolis told Meyer helium could usage the gathering for different assemblage events, which had nary retail purpose, and these would beryllium considered to "enhance the commercialized district" and beryllium allowed nether the city's zoning law.
They claimed the metropolis did not behaviour a postulation study, oregon connection conditions that could beryllium imposed connected the religion to ameliorate the postulation and parking concerns.
Many of the nationalist comments astatine the nationalist proceeding demonstrated "animus and favoritism against Christ Church, its members, and their spiritual beliefs," the suit besides claimed.
The DOJ suit accuses the metropolis of Troy of violating RLUIPA by not treating Christ Church connected "equal treatment" with nonreligious assemblies done its zoning code, by imposing a "substantial burden" connected the church's spiritual workout and by discriminating against Christ Church connected the "basis of religion."
City of Troy lawyer Todd Richardson rejected the DOJ's favoritism allegations successful an interrogation with Fox News Digital. He said they’ve allowed Christ Church to clasp services successful the gathering for the past 2 years, portion the probe has been ongoing, and they person cooperated afloat with national investigators.
The Department of Justice stepped successful aft an Idaho religion claimed the municipality of Troy, Idaho was discriminating against it by denying it a zoning permit. (Kent Nishimura / Los Angeles Times via Getty Images))
TRUMP ANNOUNCES EXECUTIVE ORDER CREATING TASK FORCE TO ‘ERADICATE ANTI-CHRISTIAN BIAS’
The metropolis lawyer accused the Justice Department of utilizing "bullying tactics" to effort to unit their hand.
The lawsuit isn't astir religion, helium said, but astir the metropolis preserving the two-block downtown country arsenic a commercialized territory and resisting the influx of arsenic galore arsenic 15% of its colonisation gathering astatine 1 determination and putting a "strain connected the city’s constricted resources."
"We person nary complaints astir Christ Church being successful town. We person concerns astir overwhelming that zone," helium said.
Matt Meyer, the elder astatine Christ Church who filed a ailment with the DOJ implicit the dispute, told Fox News Digital that the religion would beryllium blessed to enactment with the metropolis to accommodate immoderate of its concerns, specified arsenic parking restrictions, but metropolis leaders "have ne'er asked america for immoderate benignant of conditions" to bash so.
Matt Meyer filed a spiritual favoritism ailment with the DOJ aft the metropolis of Troy refused to springiness his religion a conditional usage licence to clasp services successful a gathering successful its downtown area. (Getty Images)
He recovered the city's allegations astir parking and impacting businesses unfounded, saying galore of the buildings successful this downtown country are vacant, and the municipality is "largely empty" connected Sunday mornings.
Meyer attended the nationalist proceeding wherever galore residents spoke retired against the religion licence being granted. He referred to the hostile comments made by immoderate successful the assemblage toward the church, arsenic mentioned successful the DOJ lawsuit, to reason they apt played a relation successful the metropolis council's decision.
"It seems logical that elected officials could beryllium influenced by a vocal radical of residents adjacent if that radical is simply a minority, but I can’t work the caput of the metropolis council," helium said.
In April 2025, Troy passed an interim zoning ordinance that changed galore of the antecedently permitted uses successful the concern territory to "not permitted," including auditoriums, assemblage centers, civic and fraternal organizations, parks, playgrounds, schools, museums, libraries, and movie theaters, and prohibits churches arsenic a conditional use, according to the lawsuit.
In its press release, Assistant Attorney General Harmeet K. Dhillon of the Justice Department’s Civil Rights Division said, "RLUIPA unequivocally forbids section governments from deciding zoning matters based connected their dislike of definite spiritual groups. The Department of Justice volition not hesitate to record suit against jurisdictions that discriminate successful onshore usage matters connected the ground of the applicants’ spiritual beliefs."
Christ Church pastor Douglas Wilson told Fox News Digital that nationalist backlash to his opinions shouldn't beryllium a origin successful however metropolis leaders dainty his church.
"The contented of things that I accidental should person thing to bash with whether a religion is allowed to meet. You don't o.k. a spiritual assembly based upon your disagreement with definite views expressed."
CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP
The Justice Department told Fox News Digital it did not person further remark connected the matter.
Kristine Parks is simply a newsman for Fox News Digital. Read more.
English (US) ·