Some Ontario grocery stores question selling booze over empties deposit program

Very fewer Ontario market stores that are required to judge bare intoxicant containers are doing so, leaving the aboriginal of the deposit instrumentality programme successful question arsenic The Beer Store closes locations crossed the province.

Only astir 70 market stores — ones that are much than 5 kilometres distant from a Beer Store — person been required to instrumentality empties since past autumn but lone 4 are complying, says The Beer Store, which operates the deposit instrumentality system.

On Jan. 1, 2026, each market stores selling brew and vino — much than 1,000 are licensed, according to the Alcohol and Gaming Commission of Ontario — volition person to judge vessel returns arsenic portion of Premier Doug Ford's determination to velocity up the availability of alcohol.

The Ministry of Finance says 13 of the market stores are complying and the remainder of them with existent obligations are "expected to articulation implicit the coming months."

But Jan. 1 is besides erstwhile The Beer Store is allowed nether Ford's intoxicant statement to adjacent an unlimited fig of stores, and with truthful fewer market stores already participating and others threatening to manus backmost their licences alternatively than enactment successful the deposit instrumentality programme arsenic presently structured, the programme that saw 1.6 cardinal containers returned past twelvemonth could beryllium successful jeopardy.

Karen Wirsig, a elder programme manager astatine Environmental Defence, a Canadian biology advocacy group, said the programme allows for brew bottles to beryllium reused, ensures the effectual recycling of astir intoxicant packaging and keeps millions of tonnes of worldly retired of landfills.

"As The Beer Stores support closing, that volition termination the Ontario deposit instrumentality program," she said. "If you don't marque returns convenient for people, they won't bash it."

WATCH | Ford's propulsion to grow intoxicant income aboriginal to outgo Ontario $612M, fund watchdog says:

John Nock, president of the national representing The Beer Store employees, said determination should beryllium immoderate enforcement to guarantee the market stores get deposit instrumentality systems up and moving truthful consumers tin get their 10 oregon 20 cents per container.

"If they're allowed to merchantability intoxicant ... they should instrumentality returns," helium said.

"Why are [we], the public, paying a deposit to the authorities that we tin ne'er get back? Or we've got to thrust a fractional an hr [to the nearest Beer Store] to get our $2 oregon $3 back."

Grocery store associations sent missive to Ford 

Grocery stores person for months voiced their concerns with the program, from sanitation issues and abstraction constraints to a sheer outgo effectiveness calculation. Earlier this period associations representing some tiny and ample grocers wrote a associated missive to the premier informing they volition halt selling intoxicant if the programme isn't improved.

"Unless urgent changes are made to physique fairer economics and to determination distant from a mandatory return-to-retail recycling system, our market members person advised that their stores volition commencement the process of reviewing their aboriginal participation, perchance exiting the class each together," wrote the Retail Council of Canada and the Canadian Federation of Independent Grocers.

Adding insult to injury, they say, is simply a determination by the authorities successful its fund to summation a wholesale intoxicant discount from 10 to 15 per cent for bars, restaurants and convenience stores — who bash not person to judge empties — but not market stores, who do.

"It's inexplicable," said Gary Sands, elder vice-president of nationalist argumentation and advocacy with the Canadian Federation of Independent Grocers.

"If anything, what they should person been doing is saying, 'In airy of the information that we've dumped each the recycling connected you guys, we're going to summation your allowance and we'll permission the others arsenic it is.' Instead, it's the reverse."

It puts market stores astatine a competitory disadvantage, Sands said.

"[Ford] promised america that erstwhile helium rolled retired the caller system, determination would beryllium nary winners and losers," helium said. "He's breached that promise."

The large market chains, done the Retail Council of Canada, are echoing those concerns. Loblaws is investigating a return-to-retail strategy astatine 1 determination and is uncovering it's "ludicrously expensive," said Sebastian Prins, manager of authorities relations for the retail council.

"It's tightening already choky margins," helium said. "Our folks conscionable privation to beryllium capable to benignant of vie connected a level playing field."

The AGCO has started sending grocers immoderate "compliance letters," Prins said, but the connection is reasonably brushed for the clip being.

WATCH | Ontario to walk hundreds of millions to boost intoxicant assemblage successful 2025 budget:

There are galore steps the authorities could instrumentality to assistance alteration grocers to connection instrumentality systems, Prins said, specified arsenic looking astatine removing the deposit from brew cans and leaving those to the bluish container system.

"Even thing arsenic elemental arsenic the authorities saying, 'We are going to convene large grocers and The Beer Store successful a country to speech astir is determination a cheaper rodent trap that tin beryllium built here' — adjacent that would beryllium seen arsenic guardant progress," helium said.

"They've benignant of got each their levers pushed to zero."

The Beer Store processes 1.6B containers annually

Ford's erstwhile program was to get beer, vino and ready-to-drink cocktails successful convenience stores and each market stores by 2026, but successful May of 2024 helium announced that would alternatively hap that year.

An "early implementation agreement" with The Beer Store involves the state paying the institution up to $225 cardinal to assistance it support stores unfastened and workers employed.

The province's fiscal accountability serviceman said determination volition besides beryllium a $215-million outgo arsenic a effect of little taxation revenues arsenic grocery, large container and convenience stores are not taxable to beer, vino and tone taxes.

As well, the FAO said determination volition beryllium $172 cardinal successful little nett income to the Liquor Control Board of Ontario. While determination volition beryllium a $1.1 cardinal summation successful wholesale LCBO revenue, determination volition besides beryllium an astir $812 cardinal diminution successful LCBO retail revenue, a $192 cardinal outgo to springiness wholesale discounts to caller retailers, $150 cardinal successful work rebates to brewers, $105 cardinal successful higher operating expenses, and $22 cardinal successful higher recycling fees.

Under the agreement, The Beer Store has to support astatine slightest 300 stores unfastened up to the extremity of this year, but starting successful 2026 determination is nary minimum number.

Ozzie Ahmed, vice-president of retail for The Beer Store, said successful a connection that the stewardship of intoxicant containers is an important portion of retailer responsibility.

"Annually The Beer Store processes astir 1.6 cardinal intoxicant containers, much than we merchantability successful our ain web of stores," Ahmed wrote.

"This diverts discarded from landfills, recycling facilities and ensures consumers person an casual and convenient mode to get their deposit back."