The widening gap between Liverpool and Manchester United has been thrown into sharp focus once again, this time over their contrasting approaches to Newcastle United striker Alexander Isak.
Isak was left out of Newcastle’s traveling squad for their pre-season Asia tour, which begins with a friendly against Arsenal this weekend, citing a thigh injury for his omission. However, reports from the Daily Mail suggest Newcastle is also aware of Isak’s interest in exploring transfer options—one of which could be a move to Liverpool.
Isak still has three years remaining on his contract with Newcastle, and the club is keen to retain him. Newcastle’s chief executive, Darren Eales, confirmed last season that discussions about a contract extension would take place during the off-season.
Despite this, Isak is currently hesitant to commit his future to the Magpies as he considers his next steps. Meanwhile, rumors are swirling Liverpool is reportedly prepared to make him the most expensive signing in Premier League history.
Liverpool previously indicated it would be willing to offer around $162 million for Isak. However, with Newcastle firmly refusing to sell, no formal bid was made, and the club instead secured Hugo Ekitike’s signature.
Whether Liverpool will view Isak’s apparent desire to leave St James’ Park as a renewed opportunity remains uncertain. At Anfield, Isak is seen as a proven Premier League talent and a reliable option up front.
Despite spending nearly $400 million this summer, the Reds have yet to offload Darwin Nunez and have rejected offers from Bayern Munich and Barcelona for Luis Diaz, resulting in a crowded attacking lineup. A move for Isak might become viable if circumstances around Nunez and Diaz shift.
A new center-forward was United’s top priority this summer, yet over $175 million has been spent on two attackers who operate best playing off a central striker.
Club executives continue to explore the market for a true No. 9, with names like Ollie Watkins and Nicolas Jackson recently discussed— but Isak has not been among their primary targets.
Despite being regarded as one of the best in his position globally, Newcastle’s firm stance on keeping the Swedish striker led United to look elsewhere.
Even now, the financial demands of signing Isak make a deal highly unlikely. More importantly, it’s questionable whether he would leave a Champions League campaign with Newcastle to join a club that finished 15th in the Premier League last season.
Even if United could persuade him, the deal would require significant financial maneuvering. While Alejandro Garnacho is one of their most valuable trade assets, Newcastle is already well stocked in wide attacking positions, limiting the viability of any potential swap.
It just shows the gap between United and Liverpool couldn't be wider.