The case for and against Man United keeping Ruben Amorim as manager

The unit is mounting connected Manchester United brag Ruben Amorim.

In the contiguous aftermath of Wednesday's Europa League last decision to Tottenham Hotspur successful Bilbao, Spain, nine sources stressed to ESPN that the Portuguese manager retains their afloat backing. But that hasn't stopped the statement among fans connected whether helium is inactive the close antheral for the job.

A genuinely shocking Premier League run -- which could yet extremity with United conscionable 1 spot supra the relegation places successful 17th -- was capped disconnected with a miserable 1-0 decision to Spurs astatine Estadio de San Mames.

The lone affirmative of losing the Europa League last is that it volition springiness Amorim much clip connected the grooming transportation adjacent season. The large negative, however, is that the funds disposable to reshape the squad implicit the summertime volition beryllium greatly reduced aft the nine missed retired connected a imaginable £100 cardinal payday.

The lawsuit for keeping Ruben Amorim arsenic manager

Amorim is the archetypal to admit that results during his clip successful complaint haven't been bully enough. The cardinal question, though, is whether it's just to judge.

Amorim initially told United helium wanted to instrumentality implicit successful the summer. He was acrophobic that asking the players to larn a caller tactical strategy midseason would origin problems and yet helium has been proved right. He inherited a squad built for variations of a 4-3-3 formation: not his favored 3-4-3. Amorim has besides had to woody with injuries to cardinal men similar Lisandro Martínez and Amad Diallo.

It has each contributed to a wide feeling that Amorim and his unit person been successful harm regulation mode and simply trying arsenic champion they could to limp toward the extremity of the season.

There hasn't been overmuch for Amorim to outcry about, but determination person been positives. Since his appointment, United person beaten Manchester City astatine the Etihad Stadium and drawn astatine home. They drew 2-2 with Liverpool astatine Anfield and bushed Arsenal with 10 men successful the FA Cup astatine the Emirates. They were the amended squad for agelong spells during the 1-1 gully with Arsenal successful the league.

Late goals against Rangers, Southampton, Leicester, Lyon and Bournemouth suggest determination remains a warring tone wrong the radical and the players are down the manager. Bruno Fernandes, Luke Shaw and Diogo Dalot said arsenic overmuch successful the aftermath of the Europa League last decision to Tottenham connected Wednesday night.

"It's not my decision, but I bash deliberation the manager is the close 1 and I don't deliberation that it volition beryllium a amended idiosyncratic to travel into the occupation and bash the job," said Fernandes. "I cognize it's hard to recognize that, it's hard to spot that. But I inactive bash deliberation that he's the close antheral to pb the club."

Amorim isn't going to alteration his system, and past suggests it's not indispensable anyway. The bulk of Premier League managers play a saltation of 4-3-3, but Oliver Glasner has been effectual with 3-4-3 astatine Crystal Palace. Antonio Conte won the league playing with a backmost 3 erstwhile helium was successful complaint astatine Chelsea successful 2016-17. It is imaginable if it's coached successful the close mode with the close players.

The biggest tick successful Amorim's favour is that helium has done it before. He took implicit astatine a struggling Sporting CP squad and turned them into champions, winning 3 Primeira Liga titles and helping elevate players specified arsenic Viktor Gyökeres into 1 of the astir sought-after transportation targets successful Europe. Before leaving Portugal earlier this season, Amorim had a large triumph implicit Pep Guardiola successful the Champions League, and successful 2023 his broadside knocked Mikel Arteta's broadside retired of the Europa League.

His way grounds successful Portugal has to number for something. He's had a hard commencement astatine United, but it works successful his favour that helium predicted astir of it.

The large question is whether these are conscionable teething problems, oregon grounds of much profoundly embedded issues.

The lawsuit against keeping Amorim arsenic manager

play

2:48

How Manchester United tin enlistee for the rebuild

Mark Ogden talks astir Manchester United's recruitment attack to amended the squad for adjacent play nether Ruben Amorim.

Amorim's detractors person lone to constituent to his grounds successful the Premier League. United person won conscionable six of their 24 league games with Amorim successful charge. More than fractional person ended successful decision (14).

Since Amorim's assignment successful November, lone Ipswich, Leicester and Southampton -- each present relegated -- person won less games. His triumph percent of 37.8% successful each competitions is good beneath that of predecessors David Moyes, Louis van Gaal and Erik 10 Hag. It's adjacent marginally beneath Ralf Rangnick's triumph percent of 37.9% during his ill-fated caretaker spell successful 2021-22.

Most United fans similar Amorim and the mode helium has handled himself successful the job. The question immoderate ask, however, is whether helium has done capable to get the keys to the club's future. Transfer funds are tight, and United cannot spend to get recruitment decisions wrong.

One of the issues with Amorim's tactical setup is that helium has shown nary tendency to beryllium flexible. He has said repeatedly helium has "one idea" and helium has stuck to it rigidly. Eddie Howe has occasionally adapted Newcastle's tactics this play to usage a backmost 5 -- peculiarly effectual successful the Carabao Cup semifinal against Arsenal. Ange Postecoglou became much pragmatic during the Europa League run-in, which saw Spurs crowned champions connected Wednesday nighttime successful Bilbao.

Amorim, meanwhile, has refused to compromise adjacent erstwhile the program isn't working.

play

2:15

Burley: The modular of the Europa League last was shocking

The 'ESPN FC' unit enactment down the prime of the Europa League last betwixt Tottenham and Man United.

The unsocial quality of Amorim's strategy means that helium volition people privation specialists to capable circumstantial positions, whether it's helping backs oregon constrictive forwards. Recruitment astatine Old Trafford is done by committee, but Amorim stressed connected his archetypal time connected the occupation that helium needs a large say.

The information is that Amorim gets his players successful the summertime and results don't prime up. It would permission United bosses with a determination to marque successful October oregon November -- conscionable arsenic they had with Ten Hag this season.

It's imaginable that, if things don't enactment retired with Amorim, United could look to prosecute a replacement who wants to revert backmost to 4-3-3 and asks for a antithetic illustration of subordinate successful the transportation market. It would permission them facing different rebuild a twelvemonth down the enactment with small advancement to amusement for it successful the interim. All the while, Manchester City, Arsenal and Liverpool volition beryllium getting better, and the spread with the teams astatine the apical of the array volition turn wider and wider.

Sources person told ESPN that United chiefs person recovered the modulation to Amorim harder than they expected. They were hoping for immoderate benignant of bounce successful results and, successful the Premier League astatine least, it hasn't happened.

The interest is that the mediocre home signifier puts Amorim nether aggravated unit close astatine the commencement of adjacent season. In that sense, determination are similarities with Ten Hag past summertime and that ended successful the Dutchman's sacking earlier Christmas.