Who should Tottenham Hotspur sign, Dennis Cirkin or Kyle Walker-Peters? - Opinion

Tottenham Hotspur person been linked with Kyle Walker-Peters and Dennis Cirkin and choosing which 1 would beryllium the amended signing is simply a adjacent call, but 1 of them conscionable edges it.

Tottenham are playing the agelong crippled successful the summertime transportation window. It whitethorn person been unfastened for the champion portion of the month, but the lone players Spurs person signed are Kevin Danso and Mathys Tel, who were already connected indebtedness astatine the nine past season.

However, this could soon change, arsenic determination is grounds that Tottenham are moving towards bringing caller players to Hotspur Way. Most notably, Spurs person had a bid rejected for Mohammed Kudus. The West Ham winger is apt to beryllium disposable for a terms importantly beneath his £85m merchandise clause, truthful determination is content that a woody volition yet beryllium agreed.

Supporters person mixed feelings astir the anticipation of Kudus joining, but his rumoured determination to the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium is surely much fashionable than the imaginable instrumentality of a erstwhile Spurs full-back.

Tottenham are 1 of a fewer clubs funny successful Kyle Walker-Peters. He is not the lone defender to beryllium linked with a instrumentality to North London, arsenic Spurs are expected to marque an connection for Dennis Cirkin. Both players person their pros and cons, but which would beryllium the amended signing?

Comparing Tottenham transportation targets Kyle Walker-Peters and Dennis Cirkin

Re-signing an aged subordinate who ne'er truly made it arsenic a Lilywhite whitethorn not origin overmuch excitement, but determination is simply a bully crushed for it. Spurs request much locally trained and homegrown players and some Walker-Peters and Cirkin are susceptible players.

Walker-Peters made 33 Premier League appearances past season. This could really beryllium viewed arsenic thing negative, considering helium played successful 1 of the worst teams successful English top-flight history. However, helium has plentifulness of Premier League experience, arsenic good arsenic having played successful the Champions League during his erstwhile spell astatine Tottenham.

Cirkin has little to boast about, arsenic helium has ne'er made a Premier League appearance. He spent his archetypal play astatine Sunderland successful League One and has played 3 consecutive campaigns successful the Championship. The 23-year-old made 39 appearances past season, including the play-offs, and registered 3 goals and 2 assists.

Sunderland kept 11 cleanable sheets erstwhile Cirkin was connected the transportation past season, portion Southampton lone managed 2 erstwhile Walker-Peters played. Cirkin averaged 2.5 tackles per game, 1.2 much than Walker-Peters, but the Southampton antheral made 1.2 much shot recoveries connected mean per game.

However, it is hard to marque a determination based connected past season’s performances. Walker-Peters played for a mediocre squad successful a apical league, portion Cirkin represented a beardown squad successful the 2nd tier. The cardinal to deciding which subordinate Spurs should motion is by looking to the aboriginal and identifying which would beryllium amended for a three-year task nether Thomas Frank.

Tottenham should motion Dennis Cirkin

If Tottenham were signing 1 of their ex-players arsenic a first-team defender, Walker-Peters whitethorn beryllium the amended pick. He has proven himself astatine a higher level, portion Cirkin remains untested successful the Premier League.

However, the incoming subordinate is going to beryllium Pedro Porro oregon Destiny Udogie’s understudy. Therefore, Cirkin is the amended enactment due to the fact that helium has much years to make into a much implicit player. He is 5 years younger than Walker-Peters and has conscionable played the champion play of his career. Walker-Peters, connected the different hand, volition not person galore years to offer.

The 28-year-old would beryllium disposable arsenic a escaped agent, but Cirkin is worthy spending immoderate wealth connected due to the fact that Spurs are getting a subordinate who tin larn and turn arsenic a player. The ceiling of his abilities remains unseen and helium could go acold much than conscionable a homegrown seat warmer.

Whichever full-back Tottenham determine to bring successful volition person their ain benefits, but Cirkin is much breathtaking and is much successful enactment with the club’s caller signings.

READ MORE – Why Thomas Frank could beryllium the crushed down Tottenham’s deficiency of transportation urgency